• Apgrejdovali smo forum na XenForo 2.1.1, ukoliko imate predloga vezanih za izgled ili funkcionalnost foruma, ili ukoliko naletite na neki problem, javite nam OVDE

    DEFINISALI SMO PRAVILA FORUMA. Pročitajte ih, pojaviće se automatski kada krenete da čitate nešto!

AMD: QA Consultants ocenila rad grafičkih drajvera

PCAXE_news

PCAXE Addicted
Učlanjen(a)
28.07.2009.
Poruka
5.778
Rezultat reagovanja
395
Moja konfiguracija


Nezavisna kompanija „QA Consultants", koja je specijalizovana za nezavisnu proveru kvaliteta i pouzdanosti softvera, objavila je novi izveštaj u kome se navodi da AMD ima najstabilnije drajvere u industriji grafičkih procesora.

Prema saopštenjima čelnika, AMD bazirani sistemi su prošli 401 od 432 testa, dok su NVIDIA sistemi prošli 356 testova pouzdanosti.

„QA Consultants" su testirali šest najpopularnijih AMD grafičkih akceleratora.

Opširnije...
 

Kobatz

Moderator
Učlanjen(a)
03.04.2009.
Poruka
6.540
Rezultat reagovanja
631
Moja konfiguracija
PC / Laptop Name:
Nzxt
CPU & cooler:
Amd Ryzen 1600 ~ 4.1ghz 24/h
Motherboard:
Msi x450 gaming
RAM:
4 x 4gb Kingston fury 2400 ~ 3000mhz by Micron
VGA & cooler:
Gigabyte 3060ti oc 8gb
Display:
Asus vs27 27' + Denver 56' lcd -madvr+ hitachi projector
HDD:
Adata sx8000 480gb+Kingston 480gb +2x 1.5tb by zamzung
Sound:
Asus Xonar Dx
Case:
Nzxt Apollo case,slight mod
PSU:
Raidmax 530w
Optical drives:
Liteon writer
Mice & keyboard:
Logitech g3,saitek eclipse II
Internet:
sbb 50/4
OS & Browser:
Windows 11,chrome&ff
Other:
Nexus 7' 2013, Htpc i7 2600, rx580 8gb madvr 4k60fps high conf
Sta li ce Nvidia lovery da kazu na ovo:)

Sent from my D6603 using Tapatalk
 

Typhoon.X

Moderator
Učlanjen(a)
12.04.2009.
Poruka
1.219
Rezultat reagovanja
221
Moja konfiguracija
PC / Laptop Name:
Seraphim/Azrael
CPU & cooler:
AMD Ryzen 3700X | AC Liquid Freezer II 360
Motherboard:
X570 Aorus Elite
RAM:
2x16GB G.Skill TridentZ Neo 3600Mhz 16-19-19-39
VGA & cooler:
GIGABYTE GeForce GTX 1080 Ti Gaming OC 11G
Display:
DeLL G3223D
HDD:
A-Data SX8200 Pro 512GB + Crucial P1 1TB + Seagate ST1000VX000 + WDC WD20EARX
Sound:
FX-AUDIO DAC-X6
Case:
NZXT H710
PSU:
CM V1200 Platinum
Optical drives:
Xternal LG GP08NU6W
Mice & keyboard:
Corsair K70 RGB Mk.2 (MX Brown) | Logitech G502 Lightspeed
Internet:
SBB Cable 300/30
OS & Browser:
Microsoft Windows 10 Pro x64 | Firefox
Other:
Dell Latitude 5400 | Mikrotik hAp ax3 | Galaxy S21 Ultra | Sennheiser HD518
Source

Commissioned by AMD
'nuff said...

Pored toga, kako je covek lepo objasnio na G3D forumu :

Tough call...

AMD did pay for this test. Literally. And I doubt they would go ahead and publish had the results been negative for AMD.
So I have trouble calling this an independent testing.

But then again this is MS standard GPU stress test, so the results should count for something.

Then again the results are heavily skewed by PRO cards failing too frequently, like for example P600 failing 31 out of 72 tests, while 1080 Ti fails only 2 out of 72 tests.
How is it possible that p600 is "supported" let alone that this driver is marked as WHQL, if the card fails 50% tests??

Going even further: It doesn't looks like MS testing prerequisites were met, with QA failing to meet the very first prerequisite:
At least two test computers for every discrete device family in the INF file that is being certified.
Graphic Adapter or Chipset Testing Prerequisites


I stopped reading "Graphic Adapter or Chipset Testing Prerequisites" because whats the point if QA consultants fail at the 1st prerequisite. I think its a safe bet that there are more testing errors.

All this does not mean I would let Nvidia off the hook that easily.
I would really like to know what happened here.
BTW, imao sam vise i AMD i nV karti u masini tokom prethodnih par godina, nikada nisam imao problema sa driver crash-evima ni sa jednom od njih...
 

Kobatz

Moderator
Učlanjen(a)
03.04.2009.
Poruka
6.540
Rezultat reagovanja
631
Moja konfiguracija
PC / Laptop Name:
Nzxt
CPU & cooler:
Amd Ryzen 1600 ~ 4.1ghz 24/h
Motherboard:
Msi x450 gaming
RAM:
4 x 4gb Kingston fury 2400 ~ 3000mhz by Micron
VGA & cooler:
Gigabyte 3060ti oc 8gb
Display:
Asus vs27 27' + Denver 56' lcd -madvr+ hitachi projector
HDD:
Adata sx8000 480gb+Kingston 480gb +2x 1.5tb by zamzung
Sound:
Asus Xonar Dx
Case:
Nzxt Apollo case,slight mod
PSU:
Raidmax 530w
Optical drives:
Liteon writer
Mice & keyboard:
Logitech g3,saitek eclipse II
Internet:
sbb 50/4
OS & Browser:
Windows 11,chrome&ff
Other:
Nexus 7' 2013, Htpc i7 2600, rx580 8gb madvr 4k60fps high conf
Source



'nuff said...

Pored toga, kako je covek lepo objasnio na G3D forumu :



BTW, imao sam vise i AMD i nV karti u masini tokom prethodnih par godina, nikada nisam imao problema sa driver crash-evima ni sa jednom od njih...
Ni ja,al opet gomila po netu kuka na amd drajvere:)

Sent from my D6603 using Tapatalk
 

Dexter013

PCAXE Addicted
Učlanjen(a)
19.06.2013.
Poruka
5.685
Rezultat reagovanja
332
Moja konfiguracija
PC / Laptop Name:
Dark Knight
CPU & cooler:
Ryzen 7600x 5ghz + Aorus800
Motherboard:
AM5 MSI tomahawk B650
RAM:
32gb DDR5, 2x16GB 6400MHz kingston fury
VGA & cooler:
RTX 4070ti Gianward OC
Display:
Philips 32 / 2K / 1440p / 75hz
HDD:
Crusial ssd 500 gb + 500 gb Samsung HDD + Samsung 1TB ssd 870 evo
Sound:
default
Case:
Coller Master MASTERCASE H500 RGB window
PSU:
Corsair CX 850w M
Optical drives:
None
Mice & keyboard:
Logitech Hyperion + Natec RX22
Internet:
Optika MTS 500/160
OS & Browser:
Win 11 x64 PRO Legalan bato...
Other:
TV LG 55 4k
Ja kod mene gtx 970 kod zene amd 280x vec duze vreme,
nIkad problem ni kod mene ni kod nje, nije mi bas jasno kako ljudi kukaju stalno na te gpu drajvere, sta im bre rade?!
 

Gulftown

PCAXE OC team
Učlanjen(a)
23.01.2011.
Poruka
6.727
Rezultat reagovanja
1.534
Moja konfiguracija
PC / Laptop Name:
ASUS ROG G73Jh
CPU & cooler:
R5 5900X EK Water Cooling - i7 990X - R5 3600
Motherboard:
X570 Crosshair VIII Hero WiFI - Asus Rampage III Black Edition - AsRock Fatal1ty B450 Gaming-ITX/ac
RAM:
G.Skill TridentZ 4000 2x8Gb - Corsair Dominator 6x2Gb - 2x8Gb ADATA
VGA & cooler:
6900XT Waterforce - MSI Lightning 7970 CrossFire - GT 1030
Display:
ROG STRIX XG43VQ
HDD:
Samsung 970 Evo Plus 1TB x2 - Samsung EVO 250GB -Samsung EVO 250GB - 8TB WD Purple, 2TB WD Green
Case:
Lian Li 011 Dynamic - Bench Table - Fractal Node 304
PSU:
Cooler Master V1000 - Cooler Master V1200 - CM 500W
Mice & keyboard:
MX Master 3, HyperX Alloy Elite RGB Cherry MX Blue
OS & Browser:
Windows 10
Sve sami strucnjaci za drajvere to pisu.

Sent from my Mi A1 using Tapatalk
 
Vrh