[Procesor] Obračun na 4GHz - AMD vs Intel by FantomX & Lukija

Diskusija u 'Testovi korisnika' započeta od Lukija, 28.08.2010.

  1. Lukija

    Lukija PCAXE Eminent Guru

    2.564
    0
    300
    13.04.2009
    Moja konfiguracija
    Cilj testa je poređenje AMD/Intel platforme kroz bateriju gejming testova i nešto sintetike. Kao referentna grafička karta, izabrana je ATI HD5870 grafička karta. Naravno, za potrebe testa, kartice su blago overclock-ovane tako da realno mogu da se koriste u 24/7 režimu. Na oba sistema su instalirani 10.7 Catalyst drajveri a testiranje je izvršeno baterijom sledećih testova (setovanja možete pogledati na slikama koje slede):

    - 3DMark06
    - 3DMarkVantage
    - Crysis WarHead benchmark tool 0.33
    - S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat benchmark


    Svi testovi su rađeni u tri najpopularnije rezolucije (1280x1024, 1680x1050, 1920x1200) uz korišćenje naprednih opcija ( 8x antialiasing i 16x anisotropic filtering).

    Kako je Core i7 platforma prisutna već duže vreme, za poređenje smo iskoristili trenutni top-notch sistem kompanije AMD.

    Na sledećoj slici se nalaze specifikacije testiranih sistema:

    [​IMG]

    Slike sistema:

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]


    Slike setovanja sistema:

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]

    Benčmark setovanja:

    3DMark06:

    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]

    3DMarkVantage:

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    Crysis WarHead:

    [​IMG]

    S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat benchmark:


    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    I verni posmatrač Lucko:

    [​IMG]

     
    Poslednja izmena: 28.08.2010
  2. Lukija

    Lukija PCAXE Eminent Guru

    2.564
    0
    300
    13.04.2009
    Moja konfiguracija
    Rezultati:

    3DMark06, 1280x1024 8xAA 16xAF

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]

    3DMark06, 1680x1050 8xAA 16xAF

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]

    3DMark06, 1920x1200 8xAA 16xAF

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]



    3DMarkVantage, Performance

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]

    3DMarkVantage, High

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]

    3DMarkVantage, Xtreme

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]



    Crysis WarHead

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]




    S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat Benchmark, 1280x1024

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]

    S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat Benchmark, 1680x1050

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]

    S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat Benchmark, 1920x1200

    AMD

    [​IMG]

    Intel

    [​IMG]



     
  3. Lukija

    Lukija PCAXE Eminent Guru

    2.564
    0
    300
    13.04.2009
    Moja konfiguracija

    Za kraj testa su urađeni i grafikoni, za one koji vole takvu vrstu prikaza.


    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]


     
  4. Lukija

    Lukija PCAXE Eminent Guru

    2.564
    0
    300
    13.04.2009
    Moja konfiguracija

    Nastavak

    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]

    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]

    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]

    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]

    [​IMG][​IMG][​IMG]



    Neka slike govore za sebe.

    FantomX, Lukija & Lucko :sekira:
     
    Poslednja izmena: 28.08.2010
  5. animaN

    animaN Administrator Urednik

    9.370
    28
    300
    28.03.2009
    BG-Kaludjerica
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    Ci7 3930K@ Coolink CoratorDS
    Motherboard:
    ASUS P9X79 Deluxe
    RAM:
    4x4GB Mushkin 1600 MHz cl9, 1.5V
    VGA & cooler:
    Sapphire HD6950 FleX Edition
    Display:
    3x Belinea 102035W
    HDD:
    Corsair ForceGT 120GB SSD,WD AAKS 640 GB, WD MyBook 500GB
    Sound:
    Realtek ALC889 - Logitech Z2300
    Case:
    Cooler Master bench table
    PSU:
    Cooler Master Silent Pro 850W
    Optical drives:
    USB LiteOn
    Mice & keyboard:
    Logitech G15 - Logitech MX518
    Internet:
    SBB 10/1 Mbit
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 7 x64 SP1
    Other:
    Volim AXE
    Svaki komentar je suvishan...Bravo momci, pokidali ste! :first:

    :sekira:
     
  6. Shiki

    Shiki PCAXE OC team

    1.609
    0
    300
    01.04.2009
    Beograd, Zvezdara
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    .
    RAM:
    4GB DDR3 1066MHz
    Display:
    LG LC55 42"
    HDD:
    Kingston V+ 128GB|WD GREEN 1TB (Icy Box)| 160GB WD Passport
    Sound:
    Logitech Z5500
    Mice & keyboard:
    Apple Magic Mouse|Apple Wireless Keyboard
    Internet:
    Cable 8096/384
    OS & Browser:
    Snow Leopard 10.6.6 :)
    Other:
    Macbook White Unibody
    Skidam kapu, svaka cast stvarno.

    BTW neverovatno je kako cifre variraju, negde je Intel bolji, negde AMD, pa sa promenom rezolucije se opet okrene situacija da bi se sa ponovnom promenom rezolucije opet stvari vratile na "prvobitno" stanje... Stvarno extra.

    Josh jednom, skidam kapu ;)

    :wave:
     
  7. illidan

    illidan PCAXE Addicted

    4.382
    0
    300
    01.04.2009
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    xeon
    vrh!

    lucko je bas uzivao :D
     
  8. animaN

    animaN Administrator Urednik

    9.370
    28
    300
    28.03.2009
    BG-Kaludjerica
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    Ci7 3930K@ Coolink CoratorDS
    Motherboard:
    ASUS P9X79 Deluxe
    RAM:
    4x4GB Mushkin 1600 MHz cl9, 1.5V
    VGA & cooler:
    Sapphire HD6950 FleX Edition
    Display:
    3x Belinea 102035W
    HDD:
    Corsair ForceGT 120GB SSD,WD AAKS 640 GB, WD MyBook 500GB
    Sound:
    Realtek ALC889 - Logitech Z2300
    Case:
    Cooler Master bench table
    PSU:
    Cooler Master Silent Pro 850W
    Optical drives:
    USB LiteOn
    Mice & keyboard:
    Logitech G15 - Logitech MX518
    Internet:
    SBB 10/1 Mbit
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 7 x64 SP1
    Other:
    Volim AXE
    Bogme u STALKER-u razlika nikako nije mala i akademska...Nisam znao da je ta igra toliko osetljiva na broj jezgara. Moze lako da se desi da bez HT-a na Intelu vrednosti skoche ;)

    :wave:
     
  9. BigJoe

    BigJoe PCAXE OC team

    2.788
    1
    300
    28.03.2009
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    Intel Core i7-920 (D0) & TRUE Black + 2x Noctua P12
    Motherboard:
    Intel DX58SO
    RAM:
    3x2GB OCZ Reaper 1600 CL7
    VGA & cooler:
    ATi Radeon HD5850 by GA
    Display:
    SAMSUNG SM 206BW
    HDD:
    ~3,5TB
    Sound:
    Realtek ALC889
    Case:
    CM Stacker 830 Black + X Craft 350 + SCYTHE KAZA MASTER
    PSU:
    TT ToughPower 1500W
    Optical drives:
    Lite-ON LH-20A1S & SAMSUNG SH-S223L
    Mice & keyboard:
    Logitech MX1000 + G500 + G11
    Internet:
    ADSL 4Mb/256Kb
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 7 x64
    Other:
    HTC Desire, iPod Classic Black 80GB
    Odlično :sekira:
     
  10. Luka

    Luka PCAXE Member

    294
    0
    150
    29.06.2010
    Beograd
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    Athlon II X3 425
    Motherboard:
    MSI 770-G45
    RAM:
    2x2 GB Kingston DDR3 @ 1600MHz CL8
    VGA & cooler:
    MSI Cyclone HD4770
    Display:
    Prestigio P3222W
    HDD:
    Western Digital WD5000AAKS
    Sound:
    Integrale
    Case:
    Lc Power 914B II
    PSU:
    LC 600w
    Optical drives:
    Samsung SH-S223C
    Mice & keyboard:
    MX518 / Logitech no name
    Internet:
    SBB 10Mbit
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 8.1
    Other:
    SteelSeries QcK
    Svaka cast,odlicni testovi!
     
  11. FantomX

    FantomX GPU Guru

    4.845
    0
    300
    01.04.2009
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    iMac 24"
    Other:
    ¿ʞɔnɟ əɥʇ ʇɐɥʍ
    Cele je na svom testu sa 965BE imao bolje skorove od i7 920, izgleda da stalkeru vise prija AMD. :)

    Hvala na cestitkama, bilo je vredno ulozenog truda. :sekira:
     
    Poslednja izmena: 29.08.2010
  12. animaN

    animaN Administrator Urednik

    9.370
    28
    300
    28.03.2009
    BG-Kaludjerica
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    Ci7 3930K@ Coolink CoratorDS
    Motherboard:
    ASUS P9X79 Deluxe
    RAM:
    4x4GB Mushkin 1600 MHz cl9, 1.5V
    VGA & cooler:
    Sapphire HD6950 FleX Edition
    Display:
    3x Belinea 102035W
    HDD:
    Corsair ForceGT 120GB SSD,WD AAKS 640 GB, WD MyBook 500GB
    Sound:
    Realtek ALC889 - Logitech Z2300
    Case:
    Cooler Master bench table
    PSU:
    Cooler Master Silent Pro 850W
    Optical drives:
    USB LiteOn
    Mice & keyboard:
    Logitech G15 - Logitech MX518
    Internet:
    SBB 10/1 Mbit
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 7 x64 SP1
    Other:
    Volim AXE
    Ako nije problem, pokushajte i bez HT-a na Intelu. Ja sam imao neke kontradiktorne rezultate sa ukljuchenim HT-om kod nekih igara...
    Svaka chast josh jednom za opshiran i uredan test (moj tip testa definitivno :)).

    :sekira:
     
  13. FantomX

    FantomX GPU Guru

    4.845
    0
    300
    01.04.2009
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    iMac 24"
    Other:
    ¿ʞɔnɟ əɥʇ ʇɐɥʍ
    Probacemo i to, sada malo predaha i uzivanja. :)

    one axe to rule them all!
     
  14. animaN

    animaN Administrator Urednik

    9.370
    28
    300
    28.03.2009
    BG-Kaludjerica
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    Ci7 3930K@ Coolink CoratorDS
    Motherboard:
    ASUS P9X79 Deluxe
    RAM:
    4x4GB Mushkin 1600 MHz cl9, 1.5V
    VGA & cooler:
    Sapphire HD6950 FleX Edition
    Display:
    3x Belinea 102035W
    HDD:
    Corsair ForceGT 120GB SSD,WD AAKS 640 GB, WD MyBook 500GB
    Sound:
    Realtek ALC889 - Logitech Z2300
    Case:
    Cooler Master bench table
    PSU:
    Cooler Master Silent Pro 850W
    Optical drives:
    USB LiteOn
    Mice & keyboard:
    Logitech G15 - Logitech MX518
    Internet:
    SBB 10/1 Mbit
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 7 x64 SP1
    Other:
    Volim AXE
    Uzmite odmora koliko god hocete, ako razumesh shta hocu da kazem :)

    :wave:
     
  15. mipko

    mipko PCAXE Addicted

    1.309
    0
    300
    07.05.2009
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    I7 920 D0 @ 3.6GHz
    Motherboard:
    EVGA E760
    RAM:
    6x2GB Mushkin Redline 6-7-6-18-1
    VGA & cooler:
    2 x EVGA GTX 580, EVGA GTX 285 Classified
    Display:
    Lenovo L220X
    HDD:
    2XSSD 128GB Kingoston V+ 2nd gen RAID 0
    Sound:
    Asus Xonar Essence STX
    Case:
    Lian Li 2120b
    PSU:
    Antec HCP 1200
    Optical drives:
    LG
    Mice & keyboard:
    Logitech Illuminated
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 2008R2
    Other:
    Akitio Taurus Mini LCM – Portable Dual Bay RAID Enclosure
  16. Oki

    Oki PCAXE OC team

    1.866
    1
    300
    02.04.2009
    Moja konfiguracija
    Svaka chast. Ovo je bila jedna uspeshna subota ! Neki su pokushali da izadju na savu sa chamcem ali su se zeznuli dok su neki to iskoristili pametnije. Zaista svaka vam chast !
     
  17. Kerrigan

    Kerrigan PCAXE Addicted

    1.007
    0
    300
    19.11.2009
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    Intel i7 3770K @ CM Seidon 240M
    Motherboard:
    Gigabyte Z68X-UD7-B3
    RAM:
    16GB Corsair Vengeance
    VGA & cooler:
    Titan
    Display:
    3x Dell U2311H @ nVidia Surround
    HDD:
    Intel 520 240GB/Kingston V (G2) SSD 128gb/Western Digital Blue 500gb/640gb/2TB@ Scythe Himuro
    Sound:
    E-MU 1212M @ Wharfdale Diamond 10.1/Harman Kardon HK-6500
    Case:
    CoolerMaster Cosmos II
    PSU:
    Corsair TX750
    Optical drives:
    LiteOn Ez-Dub external
    Mice & keyboard:
    Corsair Vengeance K90,Logitech DiNovo Edge (backup :P),Logitech MX Air/G500/G9x
    Internet:
    20mb Fiber Optic
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 7 64bit
    :eek: svaka cast !!!
     
  18. Cele303

    Cele303 PCAXE Apprentice

    62
    0
    50
    14.11.2009
    Rijeka
    Moja konfiguracija
    PC / Laptop Name:
    Mister bombastik
    CPU & cooler:
    i7 3930K C2 @ 4.6GHz 1.33V, Noctua NH-D14
    Motherboard:
    MSI Big Bang - XPower II
    RAM:
    G.Skill Ripjaws Z 4x4GB 2133MHz
    VGA & cooler:
    Sapphire 7970 @ 1100/1500
    Display:
    Dell U2711
    HDD:
    Mushkin Chronos 120GB SSD, 2x 1TB Seagate HDD
    Sound:
    Logitech G930
    Case:
    CoolerMaster HAF 932 Advanced
    PSU:
    Corsair AX 1200W
    Optical drives:
    Nec dvd/rw
    Mice & keyboard:
    Logitech G9x & G19
    Internet:
    FTTH 26Mb/1.25Mb
    OS & Browser:
    Win 7 X64 Enterprise SP1
    Skypam se sad sa Okijem i dao mi link na temu, svaka čast momci!

    Kako se ono kaže, veliki umovi misle isto :D Ja zadnjih 10 dana radim 1090T vs i7 930 4GHz battle :)

    Ako se nitko ne ljuti, uletio bi sa svojim rezultatima na ovu temu da bude još bogatija... :)

    Prvi setup bi bio

    Intel i7 930
    Gigabyte EX58-UD5
    3x2GB Corsair Dominator GT 1866 7-8-7-20
    Noctua NH-D14
    2x Ati 5870
    Corsair TX850W

    Drugi setup bi bio

    AMD X6 1090T
    Gigabyte 890FXA-UD5
    2x2GB Corsair Dominator GT 1866 7-8-7-20
    Noctua NH-D14
    2x Ati 5870
    Corsair TX850W
     
  19. Beagle

    Beagle PCAXE News Guru

    1.480
    0
    300
    20.01.2010
    Vukov Spomenik
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    AthlonII X4 620 @1.225v, Hyper 412 Slim
    Motherboard:
    Gigabyte M720-US3
    RAM:
    2x2GB Patriot Viper + 2x2GB GEIL Black Dragon CL5-5-5-15 @800 @1.8v
    VGA & cooler:
    Gigabyte GF9500GT 1GB (750/1850/500), CoolViva Z1
    Display:
    LG L204WS
    HDD:
    Patriot Pyro 60 GB, WD5001AALS
    Sound:
    Creative Audigy 1, Altec Lansing ATP3, Beyerdynamic DTX-710
    Case:
    Lian Li PC-S80 Black, 2xScythe SlipSream, 1x Turbine Master 800RPM
    PSU:
    OCZ StealthXStream 500W (Scythe S-Flex ventilator)
    Optical drives:
    Optiarc DVD-RW
    Mice & keyboard:
    Microsoft sidewinder X5, Roccat Taito, Logitech K120
    Internet:
    Cable
    OS & Browser:
    Win 7x64 SP1
    Other:
    Audigy front panel
    AMD je objasnio :d
     
  20. animaN

    animaN Administrator Urednik

    9.370
    28
    300
    28.03.2009
    BG-Kaludjerica
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    Ci7 3930K@ Coolink CoratorDS
    Motherboard:
    ASUS P9X79 Deluxe
    RAM:
    4x4GB Mushkin 1600 MHz cl9, 1.5V
    VGA & cooler:
    Sapphire HD6950 FleX Edition
    Display:
    3x Belinea 102035W
    HDD:
    Corsair ForceGT 120GB SSD,WD AAKS 640 GB, WD MyBook 500GB
    Sound:
    Realtek ALC889 - Logitech Z2300
    Case:
    Cooler Master bench table
    PSU:
    Cooler Master Silent Pro 850W
    Optical drives:
    USB LiteOn
    Mice & keyboard:
    Logitech G15 - Logitech MX518
    Internet:
    SBB 10/1 Mbit
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 7 x64 SP1
    Other:
    Volim AXE
    @Cele303

    Bravo majstore! Jedva chekam i tvoj update teme!

    :wave:
     
  21. BEGINER

    BEGINER PCAXE Addicted

    1.740
    3
    300
    01.04.2009
    Bgd-Filmski Grad
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    Intel Core i5 4440 @ 3.10GHz
    Motherboard:
    ASUSTeK COMPUTER INC. Z97-K
    RAM:
    16,0GB Kingston Crveni txn Proka
    VGA & cooler:
    1023MB NVIDIA GeForce GTX 750
    Display:
    Neka 24orka, ocekuje se 32
    HDD:
    Patriot Blast ssd 240
    Sound:
    pojma neam
    Case:
    Xigmatek Elysium
    PSU:
    Seasonic 850w
    Optical drives:
    pojma neam
    Mice & keyboard:
    Logi i Logi svasta
    Internet:
    Ikom 200Mbita
    OS & Browser:
    Win 7 x64
    Other:
    MONEY & PUSSY LOVER
    Svaka cast momci :appl: odlicni testovi,kao sto je receno,opsirno vrhunski i jednom recju sjajno :rule: :rule: :rule: :rule:
     
  22. drfedja

    drfedja CPU Guru

    3.078
    11
    300
    01.04.2009
    Swaziland, Hoho - Mbabane
    Moja konfiguracija
    PC / Laptop Name:
    Dell n5010, Intel Core i3 370M 2.4 GHz, 4 GB DDR3 1333
    CPU & cooler:
    Intel Core i7 4790K @ 4.5 GHz
    Motherboard:
    Biostar Hi-Fi Z97WE
    RAM:
    16GB Kingston HyperX Beast 2400
    VGA & cooler:
    Sapphire AMD Radeon R9-280X
    Display:
    Viewsonic VA2342 23" LED, LG 25"Ultrawide, Samsung VA2342 23"
    HDD:
    Samsung SSD850 Evo 250GB, Kingston 120GB V300 SSD, 2x1GB WD Caviar black
    Sound:
    Altec Lansing 5100E
    Case:
    Cooler Master 690-III
    PSU:
    Cooler Master G650M modular
    Optical drives:
    N/A
    Mice & keyboard:
    Keyboard/Mouse Cooler Master Storm
    Internet:
    Cable
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 10 Pro 64-bit
    Other:
    iPhone 6S 64GB
    Opste je poznato da AMD vise ne zaostaje po pitanju gaminga za Intelom. Cak je i bolji u nekim situacijama. STALKER-u definitivno vise prija K10 arhitektura. Mozda HT prlja cache kod Intela, pa pravi pad u performansama, ali ostaje da se vidi. Jos nije izasla igra koju gura 6 jezgara.

    Jos jednom, bravo za test! :appl:

    NaSEKIRAli ste ga! :butcher:
     
  23. bosla

    bosla PCAXE Member

    115
    0
    150
    02.04.2009
    Belgrade
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    I7 870 ES @ 4.2ghz
    Motherboard:
    Gigabyte P55A-UD6
    RAM:
    2x8gb HyperX @ 2000mhz
    VGA & cooler:
    Sapphire Radeon R9 290
    Display:
    Asus MG279q
    HDD:
    SSD/Hybrid combo
    Sound:
    SB LIVE! Z
    Case:
    Define XL
    PSU:
    Thermaltake 750w
    Optical drives:
    Pioneer DVR-109
    Mice & keyboard:
    MX G700s & Microsoft Natural 4000
    Internet:
    DSL 80/6
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 10
    Fenomenalni testovi. Vrlo , VRLO informativno. Sve pohvale za ideju , trud i realizaciju!
     
  24. stoske

    stoske NC Magazin

    858
    0
    150
    13.04.2009
    Beograd
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    Dell Studio 1737 - P8400
    Motherboard:
    Dell
    RAM:
    4GB
    VGA & cooler:
    ATi 3650 256 RAM
    Display:
    17" 1440x900
    HDD:
    1TB
    Sound:
    Integrisani HD Audio
    Optical drives:
    BluRay burner Slot-In
    Mice & keyboard:
    Dell
    Internet:
    Kablovski
    OS & Browser:
    Windows 7 Ultimate
    Other:
    2Mpx camera
    Odlican test, kratko i jasno. Za svaku pohvalu.
     
  25. Diabolique

    Diabolique PCAXE OC team

    2.705
    0
    300
    01.04.2009
    Jerković brate
    Moja konfiguracija
    CPU & cooler:
    E5200
    Motherboard:
    P5Q
    RAM:
    2x2GB
    VGA & cooler:
    5770
    Display:
    DIY Projektor
    HDD:
    10001FALS, 10EACS, 10EADS
    Sound:
    Audigy@Z5500
    Case:
    Generic
    PSU:
    CM 450 RP
    Optical drives:
    Pioneer 215D
    Mice & keyboard:
    MS Natural 4000, MX1100R
    Internet:
    IKOM 2Mb
    OS & Browser:
    Win XP
    Ideja vam je odlična. Verujem da mnogo korisnika ima dilemu, šta kupiti.

    Odličan test!
    Svaka čast.
     

Preporučite stranicu